The importance of early detection of ENT symptoms in mild-to-moderate COVID-19
Objectives. Patients with coronavirus disease-19 (COVID-19) caused by severe acute res- piratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) may present with a wide range of symp- toms. In this paper, a detailed characterisation of mild-to-moderate ear, nose nd throat (ENT) symptoms is presented with the aim of recognising the disease early to help reduce further spread and progression.
Methods. A total of 230 cases testing positive for SARS-CoV-2 and 134 negative controls were recruited for a case-control analysis. Symptoms were analysed using the Acute Respiratory Tract Infections Questionnaire, while other symptoms were investigated by ad hoc questions.
Results. Among the study samples (n = 364), 149 were males and 215 were females with age ranging from 20 to 89 years (mean 52.3). Four main groups of symptoms were ob- tained: influenza-like symptoms, ENT-symptoms, breathing issues and asthenia-related symptoms, representing 72%, 69%, 64% and 53% of overall referred clinical manifesta- tions, respectively. ENT symptoms, breathing issues and influenza-like symptoms were as- sociated with positivity to SARS-CoV-2, whereas asthenia-related symptoms did not show a significant association with SARS-CoV-2 infection after controlling for other symptoms, comorbidities and demographic characteristics.
Conclusions. ENT symptoms are equally represented with influenza-like ones as present- ing symptoms of COVID-19. Patients with ENT symptoms should be investigated for early identification and prevention of SARS-CoV-2 spread.
In December 2019, a world pandemic was caused by the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) which originated in China 1. The virus belongs to the beta coronavirus genus which has resulted in prior epidemics, notably the severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS-CoV) and Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS-CoV) 2. The virus has been noted to infect target cells by binding to the angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2), which is overexpressed in patients affected by hypertension and diabetes who are treated with ACE inhibitors and angiotensin II receptor blockers 3,4.
The resultant syndrome has been called coronavirus disease-19 (COVID-19) and has an incubation period ranging from 2 to 14 days with a variety of potentially exhibited symptoms 5. This can include asymptomatic patients as well as those with mild to moderate cases of influenza-like illnesses, without the need for hospitalisation 6-8.
In this paper, we present a case-control series focusing on mild to moderate symptoms to formulate a general overview of COVID-19. Our study has two main goals: to characterise the symptom structure of COVID-19, focusing on those that may be encountered by an otolaryngologist and to identify symptoms that could be used for early diagnosis of SARS-CoV-2 infection.
Materials and methods
Participants and procedure
Participants were recruited from those who were tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 RNA by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) on nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal swabs. Patients underwent nasal swabs at Treviso General Hospital (Italy) and were living in the same geographical area. These patients had undergone swab tests as they were either symptomatic, or had been in close contact with SARS-CoV-2 positive patients, or were healthcare professionals, and were all performed in-line with the local healthcare system COVID-19 guidelines. Only adults (≥ 18 years old) and non-hospitalised subjects were included to represent a mild-moderate spectrum of affected COVID-19 individuals, amounting to 230 patients who were self-isolating at home. We also recruited age- and sex-matched 134 controls that had negative SARS-CoV-2 PCR swabs as part of our case-control study design. Stratification of this group was not considered, in order to obtain the most general results as possible.
The study was approved by the ethics committee of Treviso and Belluno provinces, and informed consent was obtained verbally for telephone interviews.
The Acute Respiratory Tract Infections Questionnaire (ARTIQ) 9, a questionnaire commonly used to investigate symptoms of respiratory infections, was employed as well as ad hoc questions. Questionnaires were administered by the authors G.S., C.F., A.M., F.M., and P.G. by telephone interview. The ARTIQ questionnaire contains symptoms belonging to five subscales: Physical-upper respiratory tract symptoms (13 items; e.g., “Dry Cough”), Physical-lower respiratory tract symptoms (8 items; e.g., “Sweating”), symptoms connected to sleep quality (4 items; e.g., “Poor quality of sleeping”), psychological symptoms (5 items; e.g., “Difficulty in thinking clearly”), and medication usage (8 items; e.g., “Taken eye drops”). It also has 8 items that were not part of any specific subscale: 5 of them investigated other physical or psychological symptoms (e.g., “Joint pains”, “Felt dizzy”), whereas three investigated other experiences that did not directly assess symptoms (e.g., “Cancelled leisure activities”, “Taken painkillers”). Participants indicated the experience of each symptom on a three-point scale (0 = No, 1 = Yes – some, and 2 = Yes – a lot). We investigated five additional symptoms (diarrhoea, nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, and dizziness) by ad hoc questions using the same response scale, for a total of 51 items. However, the analyses focused on a subset of 40 items to better examine the configuration of the physical and psychological symptoms of SARS-CoV-2 infection, excluding those related to use of medicines and other experiences.
Participants also indicated their smoking status (current, former, never), and isolated or associated comorbidities [hypertension, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), renal disease, liver disease, cancer, cerebrovascular disease].
Characterisation of symptoms
The first goal of this study was to characterise the symptoms of infection with SARS-CoV-2. We used principal component analysis as implemented in the psych R package 10 to examine the structure of the 40 symptoms in the overall sample. Since symptoms were rated on an ordinal response scale, we analysed the polychoric correlation matrix. The scree-plot and parallel analysis 12 converged in indicating that four components provided an adequate description of the symptom structure (the first six eigenvalues were 18.34, 2.86, 2.08, 2.00, 1.65 and 1.47; the first six eigenvalues extracted from randomly resampled data were 2.94, 2.23, 2.06, 1.94, 1.84 and 1.76). Through an inspection of component loadings, we identified the first component as asthenia-related symptoms, combining both psychological symptoms and sleeping issues of the ARTIQ. The second component, i.e. Ear, Nose, Throat (ENT) symptoms, mainly reflected physical-upper respiratory tract symptoms. The third component (influenza-like) included mostly influenza-like symptoms, also including gastrointestinal symptoms, whereas the last component (breathing-issues) received the highest loadings by symptoms connected with breathing issues. The four components all correlated with each other (RS ranging between 0.31 and 0.46). We saved component scores to use in subsequent analyses.
For each symptom component, we defined a set of marker symptoms, symptoms that showed a primary loading > 0.40 on that component and whose remaining loadings were at most half of their primary one. These symptoms were thus those more clearly connected with a certain component, and not being as strongly connected to other components.
We further investigated whether marker symptoms would allow the identification of SARS-CoV-2 infection. We performed logistic regression analysis in which we regressed the diagnosis (1 = positive vs 0 = negative) on age, gender, smoking status, the three most frequent health conditions (hypertension, cardiovascular diseases and diabetes), and the principal component scores for each symptom component.
A total of 364 individuals (149 males and 215 females) were recruited for the study with ages ranging from 20 to 89 years (mean 52.3, SD = 15.8). 217 cases (94.3%) and 110 controls (82.1%) were never/former smokers, while 11 patients (4.8%) and 24 controls (17.9%) were ever smokers, respectively (P < 0.001). Comorbidities were observed in 146 cases (63.3%) and 39 controls (29.0%) (Tab. I). Even if hypertension, cardiovascular diseases and diabetes were significantly more prevalent in cases (Tab. I), a chi-square test for independence showed that the pattern of comorbidities was not significantly different between cases and controls, χ2(7) = 9.58, P = 0.222.
Symptoms in SARS-CoV-2 positive subjects
Component loadings are reported in Table II. First we focused on the mere presence of any of the marker symptoms for each cluster and overall. Table III shows the proportion of cases and controls who reported none of the marker symptoms (column “Absent”), the proportion of those who reported at least one marker symptom, independent of whether it was reported as mildly present (Yes – some) or severely present (Yes – a lot; column “At least one”), and the proportion of those who reported at least one marker symptom as severely present (column “At least one severe”). Most patients reported at least one of the marker symptoms as at least mildly present (92%), whereas most controls (80%) did not report any marker symptom.
Second, we inspected the number of reported symptoms. For each symptom component, we computed the average number of marker symptoms, independent of whether a symptom was reported as mild or severe, and also computed the average number of severely present symptoms (Tab. IV). On average, cases reported more than one symptom for each cluster as mild or severe, whereas controls reported on average less than one symptom. A series of Welch independent samples t-tests indicated that differences among cases and controls were higher when examining reporting symptoms independent of their severity, then when focusing on symptoms reported as severe.
Indicators of SARS-CoV-2 infection
Since data were not randomly sampled from the population but were obtained using a case-control strategy, aimed at balancing the number of positive and negative subjects, positive patients were overrepresented compared to the general population. We controlled for potential biases by applying the corrections for rare-event logistic regression suggested by King and Zeng 13,14, as implemented in the relogit module of the R package Zelig 15. Using public-domain data from the Italian Civil Protection in the Veneto region on 497,045 swabs (updated to May 16th 2020) 16, we estimated that the proportion of positive cases over swabs was 3.8%. About 17% of positive subjects were hospitalised with symptoms, whereas 83% were not hospitalised. Therefore, we estimated that the probability of testing positive by a swab without being hospitalised, was about 3.1%. We used this as the estimate of the tau parameter for the rare-event logistic regression 13. The results are reported in Table V and show that males and non-smokers were more likely to be diagnosed as positive. Crucially, of the four symptom components, ENT-symptoms, breathing issues and influenza-like symptoms were associated with positivity for SARS-CoV-2, whereas asthenia-related symptoms did not show a significant association with SARS-CoV-2 infection after controlling for other symptoms, comorbidities and demographic characteristics.
According to CDC guidelines 17, COVID-19 must be suspected in case of fever or chills, cough, shortness of breath, fatigue, muscle or body aches, headache, new loss of taste or smell, sore throat, congestion or runny nose, nausea or vomiting, or diarrhoea. Among the 364 patients recruited in this study, 230 tested positive for SARS-COV-2 via nasopharynx and oropharynx swabs. Statistical analysis of data underlined that, in mild-to-moderate COVID-19, four main symptom groups may be identified using principal component analysis. These components are influenza-like symptoms, general ENT-symptoms, breathing and asthenia-related issues. Interestingly, the two latter components did not clearly mirror components identified by Aabenhus et al. 9.
In contrast to 80% of negative-swab subjects who did not exhibit any symptom, 92% of positive-swab patients presented with at least one symptom. Specifically, 72% of patients showed influenza-like symptoms, 69% showed ENT symptoms, 64% showed breathing issues and 53% asthenia-related symptoms.
When examined individually, hypertension, cardiovascular diseases and diabetes were significantly associated with SARS-CoV-2 infection. These few correlations may derive from the number of the cases analysed, which had mild-to-moderate symptoms. On the other hand, other comorbidities may have a greater impact in patients showing severe clinical manifestations 18.
Moreover, our results show a significant lower prevalence of COVID-19 in females and current smokers. This significantly reduced risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection among smokers is quite intriguing considering that smokers are usually more prone to respiratory infections. According to the authors’ personal experience, even if not validated, there is a paradoxical protective role of current smoking on COVID-19.
Viruses of the SARS-CoV-2 family have been known to cause prior pandemics; the SARS coronavirus in 2002-2003 and Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS) coronavirus in 2012. These two viruses mainly resulted in respiratory symptoms, as the infection tended to be localised in the lower airway tract 19. Literature published on SARS showed that the most frequent symptoms were persistent fever (99%), nasal symptoms (15-73%), dyspnoea (71%), headache (46.4%), cough (44.9%) and dizziness (43.5%), with diarrhoea present in only a few cases (4.3%) 20,21. An analysis of the commonest MERS symptoms by Assiri et al. 22 found that fever was present in 98% of cases, nasal symptoms in 87%, dyspnoea in 72%, cough in 47%, diarrhoea in 26% and headache in 13%.
A comparison between components of the three SARS-CoV-2 subtypes revealed that ENT symptoms are present in less than 50% of SARS and MERS patients (mean rates 44.7% and 49%, respectively), whereas they account for almost 70% in COVID-19. Conversely, influenza-like components are present in 51% of SARS, 62% of MERS and 72% of COVID-19 patients. On the other hand, breathing issues are slightly higher, with 70% of presentations in SARS and MERS (mean rates 71% and 72%, respectively), and only 64% in mild-to-moderate COVID-19. There was a high rate of discrepancy in asthenic-symptom components with rates of 78% in SARS and 53% in COVID-19.
ENT symptoms accounted for 69% of overall mild-to-moderate symptoms in our case series of positive cases. These comprised of nasal obstruction, rhinorrhoea, sneezing, ear fullness, sore throat, tearing, neck swelling, hoarseness and dizziness. In particular, among these clinical manifestations, it is worth noting that some of these symptoms (i.e. nasal obstruction, rhinorrhoea, sneezing, ear fullness, sore throat, throat discomfort) were significantly more prevalent compared to other comparable ENT ones (e.g., vertigo, chills, headache, swollen glands).
Alterations of smell and taste were previously widely evaluated by our research group. We analysed 202 patients with positive COVID-19 swabs and showed that 65% reported smell and taste alterations in addition to the other ENT symptoms reported above 23. These patients were reviewed 4 weeks after onset of their sensory changes: 50% m recovered completely, 40% had improvement and 10% had unchanged or worsened symptoms 24-26. Reports from a different study on household members with positive COVID-19 swabs found that 38% showed typical COVID-19 symptoms and 22% had these symptoms in association with altered sense of smell and taste, while 4% only had alteration of smell and taste as an isolated symptom 27. These data sets are consistent with a recent systematic review and meta-analysis on 3563 patients who had positive swab for SARS-CoV-2. The authors found that 67% of mild to moderate cases had smell or taste loss, whereas the rates among hospitalised patients was 31% 28.
ENT symptoms during the COVID-19 pandemic should be treated with caution and not underestimated. Patients with new onset nasal obstruction, sore throat and ear fullness should lead to a suspicion of COVID-19, with cases of sudden loss of smell and taste raising further alarm bells. These aspects must be taken into account together with known symptoms from World Health Organization guidance, as they can play a major role in early detection of mild to moderate SARS-CoV-2 infection. Further high-powered studies are needed to provide more concrete links to help us identify if these ENT symptoms should form part of the screening pathway for COVID-19 to be adopted by nations faced with the pandemic.
Figures and tables
|Hypertension||67 (29.1%)||12 (9.0%)||< .001|
|Cardiovascular diseases||26 (11.3%)||8 (6.0%)||.003|
|Diabetes||21 (9.1%)||3 (2.2%)||< .001|
|COPD||10 (4.3%)||7 (5.2%)||.629|
|Tumours||9 (3.9%)||5 (3.7%)||.424|
|Renal diseases||7 (3.0%)||3 (2.2%)||.344|
|Cerebrovascular diseases||5 (2.2%)||1 (0.7%)||.219|
|Hepatic diseases||1 (0.4%)||0 (0%)||-|
|Variable||Asthenia-related symptoms||ENT-symptoms||Influenza-like symptoms||Breathing issues|
|Been awake most of the night||0.91|
|Difficulty falling asleep||0.91|
|Waking up several times at night||0.79|
|Poor quality of sleeping||0.78|
|Been in a bad mood||0.64||0.26|
|Not feeling yourself||0.45||0.32||0.33|
|Painful pressure in ears||0.27||0.58|
|Tickles in the throat||0.21||0.51|
|Loss of appetite||0.30||0.48|
|Difficulty in thinking clearly||0.26||0.38||0.30|
|Shortness of breath||0.92|
|Being so unwell you had to stay in bed||0.37||0.32||0.48|
|Difficulty in going about your daily business||0.35||0.38||0.41|
|Coughing up mucus||-0.30||0.23||0.33||0.40|
|Correlation among rotated components|
|Absent||At least one||At least one severe||Absent||At least one||At least one severe|
|Asthenia-related symptoms (6 marker symptoms)||109 (47%)||121 (53%)||38 (17%)||120 (90%)||14 (10%)||8 (6%)|
|ENT symptoms (7 marker symptoms)||72 (31%)||158 (69%)||56 (24%)||110 (82%)||24 (18%)||12 (9%)|
|Influenza-like symptoms (6 marker symptoms)||64 (28%)||166 (72%)||72 (31%)||114 (85%)||20 (15%)||8 (6%)|
|Breathing issues (4 marker symptoms)||83 (36%)||147 (64%)||44 (19%)||117 (87%)||17 (13%)||5 (4%)|
|Total (23 marker symptoms)||19 (8%)||211 (92%)||122 (53%)||107 (80%)||27 (20%)||13 (10%)|
|Symptom||Mild or severe||Severe|
|M (SD)controls||M (SD)patients||t||df||p||M (SD)controls||M (SD)patients||t||df||p|
|Asthenia-related symptoms(6 marker symptoms)||0.38 (1.26)||1.47 (1.85)||6.69||353.91||< .001||0.15 (0.71)||0.39 (1.04)||2.63||353.26||.009|
|ENT-symptoms(7 marker symptoms)||0.51 (1.37)||1.86 (1.77)||8.10||333.82||< .001||0.24 (0.94)||0.38 (0.77)||1.46||237.50||.145|
|Influenza-like symptoms(6 marker symptoms)||0.43 (1.18)||1.69 (1.51)||8.86||332.31||< .001||0.12 (0.54)||0.53 (0.93)||5.40||361.94||< .001|
|Breathing issues(4 marker symptoms)||0.23 (0.70)||1.37 (1.41)||10.19||354.74||< .001||0.05 (0.31)||0.34 (0.84)||4.74||317.73||< .001|
|Total (23 marker symptoms)||1.55 (3.82)||6.39 (4.38)||11.03||309.81||< .001||0.56 (2.08)||1.65 (2.37)||4.57||308.79||< .001|
- World Health Organization Novel Coronavirus – China Disease outbreak news: Update 12 January 2020.Publisher Full Text
- Sahu KK, Mishra AK, Lal A. COVID-2019: update on epidemiology, disease spread and management. Monaldi Arch Chest Dis. 2020; 90(1)DOI
- Wan Y, Shang J, Graham R. Receptor recognition by the novel coronavirus from Wuhan: an analysis based on decade-long structural studies of SARS coronavirus. J Virol. 2020; 94:e00127-20. DOI
- Gracia-Ramos AE. Is the ACE2 overexpression a risk factor for COVID-19 infection?. Arch Med Res. 2020; 51:345-346. DOI
- Guan WJ, Ni ZY, Hu Y. Clinical characteristics of coronavirus disease 2019 in China. N Engl J Med. 2020; 382:1708-1720. DOI
- Spinato G, Gaudioso P, Boscolo Rizzo P. Risk management during COVID-19: safety procedures for otolaryngologists. Acta Biomed. 2021; 92:e2021105. DOI
- Rothe C, Schunk M, Sothmann P. Transmission of 2019-nCoV infection from an asymptomatic contact in Germany. N Engl J Med. 2020; 382:970-971. DOI
- Fabbris C, Cestaro W, Menegaldo A. Is oro/nasopharyngeal swab for SARS-CoV-2 detection a safe procedure? Complications observed among a case series of 4876 consecutive swabs. Am J Otolaryngol. 2021; 42:102758. DOI
- Aabenhus R, Thorsen H, Siersma V. The development and validation of a multidimensional sum-scaling questionnaire to measure patient-reported outcomes in acute respiratory tract infections in primary care: the acute respiratory tract infection questionnaire. Value Health. 2013; 16:987-992. DOI
- Revelle W. Procedures for Psychological, Psychometric, and Personality Research. Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois 2019 R package version 1.9.12.Publisher Full Text
- Pinheiro J, Bates D, DebRoy S. Linear and Nonlinear Mixed Effects Models. R package. 2020. Publisher Full Text
- Horn JL. A Rationale and test for the number of factors in factor analysis. Psychometrika. 1965; 30:179-185. DOI
- Tomz M, King G, Zeng L. ReLogit: Rare Events Logistic Regression. J Stat Softw. 2003; 8:1-27. DOI
- King G, Zeng L. Logistic regression in rare events data. Political Analysis. 2001; 9:137-163. DOI
- Christine C, Honaker J, Imai K. Zelig: Everyone’s Statistical Software. 2018. Publisher Full Text
- Ministero della salute.Publisher Full Text
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.Publisher Full Text
- Yang J, Zheng Y, Gou X. Prevalence of comorbidities and its effects in patients infected with SARS-CoV-2: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Infect Dis. 2020; 94:91-95. DOI
- Liu J, Zheng X, Tong Q. Overlapping and discrete aspects of the pathology and pathogenesis of the emerging human pathogenic coronaviruses SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and 2019-nCoV. J Med Virol. 2020; 92:491-494. DOI
- Hui DS, Wong PC, Wang C. SARS: clinical features and diagnosis. Respirology. 2003; 8:S20-24. DOI
- Han Y, Geng H, Feng W. A follow-up study of 69 discharged SARS patients. J Tradit Chin Med. 2003; 23:214-217.
- Assiri A, Al-Tawfiq JA, Al-Rabeeah AA. Epidemiological, demographic, and clinical characteristics of 47 cases of Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus disease from Saudi Arabia: a descriptive study. Lancet Infect Dis. 2013; 13:752-761. DOI
- Spinato G, Fabbris C, Polesel J. Alterations in smell or taste in mildly symptomatic outpatients with SARS-CoV-2 infection. JAMA. 2020; 323:2089-2090. DOI
- Boscolo-Rizzo P, Borsetto D, Fabbris C. Evolution of altered sense of smell or taste in patients with mildly symptomatic COVID-19. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2020; 146:729-732. DOI
- Boscolo-Rizzo P, Polesel J, Spinato G. Predominance of an altered sense of smell or taste among long-lasting symptoms in patients with mildly symptomatic COVID-19. Rhinology. 2020; 58:524-525. DOI
- Boscolo-Rizzo P, Menegaldo A, Fabbris C. Six-month psychophysical evaluation of olfactory dysfunction in patients with COVID-19. Chem Senses. 2021; 46:bjab006. DOI
- Boscolo-Rizzo P, Borsetto D, Spinato G. New onset of loss of smell or taste in household contacts of home-isolated SARS-CoV-2-positive subjects. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2020; 277:2637-2640. DOI
- Borsetto D, Hopkins C, Philips V. Self-reported alteration of sense of smell or taste in patients with COVID-19: a systematic review and meta-analysis on 3563 patients. Rhinology. 2020; 58:430-436. DOI
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
© Società Italiana di Otorinolaringoiatria e chirurgia cervico facciale , 2021
- Abstract viewed - 447 times
- PDF downloaded - 202 times